At this point we are all aware of the growing trend in natural pet food. People are becoming more mindful of what goes into their own bodies, so it’s only natural that we start seeing this kind of food ethic applied to our pets. We all want to make the best decisions for our animals when it comes to their health and happiness, but when cat and dog physiology is so different from our own, where do you even begin to make the most optimal choice? I’ve already discussed the risks and misleading beliefs surrounding raw food diets, but what about vegan diets? After all, countless scientific studies have confirmed the health benefits to humans, but can this be extended to cats and dogs?
Luckily there is a bit more research available on vegan pet diets than raw, though the results are highly variable. Let’s begin with looking at how cats and dogs have been shaped by evolution. That beautiful review by Buff et al. I referenced in my last post describes canine and feline physiology (as well as most sites following a simple Google search). The nutrition requirements of felines are surprisingly not all that different from their wild ancestors. Kitties have a very high protein requirement (approximately 52% of their diet should be protein), predictable for an obligate carnivore. They have teeth well-designed for tearing and shredding, not much going on in terms of grinding action (which we typically see in herbivores, or in the molars of our own teeth). Cats have a relatively short intestine, indicative of low amounts of plant processing (Case et al., Canine and Feline Nutrition 2011). All these aspects of feline physiology support the claim that they are obligate carnivores— not to mention how often my own cat brings me some poor squirrel or rat to my front door.

There have been several case studies of cats presented to the veterinarian for clinical signs due to various nutrient deficiencies. Of chief concern is taurine deficiency, which can cause dilated cardiomyopathy, a life-threatening condition if left unaddressed; reproductive failures, growth deficits, and eye problems are also common effects of taurine deficiency. Unlike dogs, who can derive taurine from other amino acid precursors, taurine is an essential amino acid in cats, and can only be derived from animal sources. It is possible to synthetically derive taurine, but it is less bioavailable than naturally-found taurine in meat, so your cat may still develop a deficiency.
Dogs on the other hand are omnivores, and as much as people want to believe that dogs should be fed like wolves, this paradoxically goes against their evolutionary history. Part of the reason we have friendly canine companions and not wild predatory wolves was the Dog’s ability to digest plant food. Dogs possess teeth for tearing and shredding, as well as grinding. They have enzymes present in the stomach and pancreas specifically designed to break down plant matter, and a longer intestine to process it (Case et al., Canine and Feline Nutrition 2011). Everything about canine physiology supports the idea that dogs are omnivores, but does this mean they can survive on a strictly plant-based diet? Humans are omnivores, and hundreds of thousands live long, healthy lives eating nothing but plants.

Bountiful evidence reveals that dogs can survive and even thrive on a strictly plant-based diet, but here’s the catch: it only works if the diet is completely balanced in all of the nuanced nutritional requirements of the Dog. An article by Dr. Heinze, a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, gives the objective facts about vegan diets for dogs. It is possible to make your dog vegan, but pet owners should take extra caution in selecting the right diet. Like conventional over the counter pet food, vegan diets vary greatly in quality. Choose one that has been AAFCO approved to ensure that it meets the baseline requirements, and that it’s been tested in home trials to guarantee that animals actually do well on it (many diets, vegan and non-vegan, don’t even meet these minimum recommendations). Dr. Heinze warns that it is much easier to improve the quality (in terms of digestibility and ingredients) when animal products are present, thus creating a high quality vegan diet poses a challenge.
One can easily find on the web evidence of many pet owners who feed their dog vegan and claim they have a shiny coat, lean body, high activity level, and reduced incidence of diabetes and other health concerns. I was quite shocked to read this, not because feeding a strictly plant-based diet to a dog seems unnatural, but because every vegan dog I’ve heard about had a dull, scratchy coat, chronic loose stools, and/or were overweight. Most veterinarians will tell you that it is fine to feed your dog vegan, but whatever you do don’t try to home-cook it, and don’t think veganism will be the best bet for your animal’s health. Though it makes sense to make your dog vegan if you are trying to avoid the environmental and farm animal welfare costs of meat consumption, it is by no means the most optimal form of nutrition.
I actually spoke to Dr. Yamate, an integrative veterinarian in Davis, about this very topic. When I asked if there is any way she would recommend a vegan diet, even for a specific medical condition, her response surprised even me: “Dogs were not evolutionarily designed to eat nothing but plants, there is no way I would ever recommend feeding a vegan diet.” Integrative medicine looks to the most wholesome, synergistic ingredients when designing a pet diet, hence Dr, Yamate’s preference for home-cooked or raw food diets. Most conventional veterinarians only care about a diet that meets all of the animal’s requirements; unlike integrative beliefs, conventional practices are not too concerned with ingredient quality, so long as the animal has all of its macro- and micronutrient needs met. Though more processing is generally involved, this can be accomplished with entirely plant food sources. When taking this into consideration, it makes sense why so many people feed their dog vegan, and why most of them do well on these diets.
After all the research I have done on raw and plant-based pet diets, and my own experience with veterinary diets and natural kibble diets, I am still at a loss for how people should feed their pets. Nutrition has no one absolute answer: every individual responds differently to various ingredients and macronutrient content. The one thing I can say with confidence is that raw food diets just aren’t worth the risk, but what about all the other endless pet food options? I myself practice a vegan lifestyle for the sake of animal welfare concerns and reducing my carbon footprint, but I’m not sure I could ever feed a dog vegan. At the moment I have cats, so veganism is simply not an option if I prioritize Milton and Oliver’s welfare over that of the animals they eat.
Someday I’ll get a dog, and given my own experience with vegan dogs generally not doing as well as omnivorous dogs, and the lack of randomized controlled studies (the gold standard for analyzing science-based evidence) to corroborate the claims made by vegan pet owners, I think I’ll stick with the high-quality kibble I know. To be fair, working with an integrative vet or veterinary nutritionist to design a whole-foods, home cooked diet may be the most optimal diet for animal health, based on the scientific reviews and claims made by vets practicing TCVM (Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine). But like I said before, I’m vegan, so there is no way I’m cooking meat when the site of raw meat makes me want to gag. To be safe, I would highly recommend feeding a high-quality, AAFCO approved kibble. These diets are much more affordable than raw or vegan diets, and you can have peace of mind that the companies were thoughtful in their diet design and were tested on real cats and dogs at home to guarantee that the theoretical benefits were actually achieved. The moral of the story: there are tons of options when it comes to pet food, some good, some bad, and some misleading choices that put your pet at risk with little benefit. Hopefully this series of posts can help in making that decision for your pets a little easier.
Images citation
Grandjean D, Buckley C, Charlton C, Merrill R, Morris P, Stevenson A. WALTHAM Pocket Book of Essential Nutrition for Cats and Dogs. Editors: Grandjean D, Butterwick R. Beyond Design Solutions Ltd, London, UK. 2009, pages 10-11





