Vegan Diets

At this point we are all aware of the growing trend in natural pet food. People are becoming more mindful of what goes into their own bodies, so it’s only natural that we start seeing this kind of food ethic applied to our pets. We all want to make the best decisions for our animals when it comes to their health and happiness, but when cat and dog physiology is so different from our own, where do you even begin to make the most optimal choice? I’ve already discussed the risks and misleading beliefs surrounding raw food diets, but what about vegan diets? After all, countless scientific studies have confirmed the health benefits to humans, but can this be extended to cats and dogs?

Luckily there is a bit more research available on vegan pet diets than raw, though the results are highly variable. Let’s begin with looking at how cats and dogs have been shaped by evolution. That beautiful review by Buff et al. I referenced in my last post describes canine and feline physiology (as well as most sites following a simple Google search). The nutrition requirements of felines are surprisingly not all that different from their wild ancestors. Kitties have a very high protein requirement (approximately 52% of their diet should be protein), predictable for an obligate carnivore. They have teeth well-designed for tearing and shredding, not much going on in terms of grinding action (which we typically see in herbivores, or in the molars of our own teeth). Cats have a relatively short intestine, indicative of low amounts of plant processing (Case et al., Canine and Feline Nutrition 2011). All these aspects of feline physiology support the claim that they are obligate carnivores— not to mention how often my own cat brings me some poor squirrel or rat to my front door.

Image result for cat vs. dog gastrointestinal physiology

There have been several case studies of cats presented to the veterinarian for clinical signs due to various nutrient deficiencies. Of chief concern is taurine deficiency, which can cause dilated cardiomyopathy, a life-threatening condition if left unaddressed; reproductive failures, growth deficits, and eye problems are also common effects of taurine deficiency. Unlike dogs, who can derive taurine from other amino acid precursors, taurine is an essential amino acid in cats, and can only be derived from animal sources. It is possible to synthetically derive taurine, but it is less bioavailable than naturally-found taurine in meat, so your cat may still develop a deficiency.

Dogs on the other hand are omnivores, and as much as people want to believe that dogs should be fed like wolves, this paradoxically goes against their evolutionary history. Part of the reason we have friendly canine companions and not wild predatory wolves was the Dog’s ability to digest plant food. Dogs possess teeth for tearing and shredding, as well as grinding. They have enzymes present in the stomach and pancreas specifically designed to break down plant matter, and a longer intestine to process it (Case et al., Canine and Feline Nutrition 2011). Everything about canine physiology supports the idea that dogs are omnivores, but does this mean they can survive on a strictly plant-based diet? Humans are omnivores, and hundreds of thousands live long, healthy lives eating nothing but plants.

Image result for cat vs. dog gastrointestinal physiology

Bountiful evidence reveals that dogs can survive and even thrive on a strictly plant-based diet, but here’s the catch: it only works if the diet is completely balanced in all of the nuanced nutritional requirements of the Dog. An article by Dr. Heinze, a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, gives the objective facts about vegan diets for dogs. It is possible to make your dog vegan, but pet owners should take extra caution in selecting the right diet. Like conventional over the counter pet food, vegan diets vary greatly in quality. Choose one that has been AAFCO approved to ensure that it meets the baseline requirements, and that it’s been tested in home trials to guarantee that animals actually do well on it (many diets, vegan and non-vegan, don’t even meet these minimum recommendations). Dr. Heinze warns that it is much easier to improve the quality (in terms of digestibility and ingredients) when animal products are present, thus creating a high quality vegan diet poses a challenge.

One can easily find on the web evidence of many pet owners who feed their dog vegan and claim they have a shiny coat, lean body, high activity level, and reduced incidence of diabetes and other health concerns. I was quite shocked to read this, not because feeding a strictly plant-based diet to a dog seems unnatural, but because every vegan dog I’ve heard about had a dull, scratchy coat, chronic loose stools, and/or were overweight. Most veterinarians will tell you that it is fine to feed your dog vegan, but whatever you do don’t try to home-cook it, and don’t think veganism will be the best bet for your animal’s health. Though it makes sense to make your dog vegan if you are trying to avoid the environmental and farm animal welfare costs of meat consumption, it is by no means the most optimal form of nutrition.

I actually spoke to Dr. Yamate, an integrative veterinarian in Davis, about this very topic. When I asked if there is any way she would recommend a vegan diet, even for a specific medical condition, her response surprised even me: “Dogs were not evolutionarily designed to eat nothing but plants, there is no way I would ever recommend feeding a vegan diet.” Integrative medicine looks to the most wholesome, synergistic ingredients when designing a pet diet, hence Dr, Yamate’s preference for home-cooked or raw food diets. Most conventional veterinarians only care about a diet that meets all of the animal’s requirements; unlike integrative beliefs, conventional practices are not too concerned with ingredient quality, so long as the animal has all of its macro- and micronutrient needs met. Though more processing is generally involved, this can be accomplished with entirely plant food sources. When taking this into consideration, it makes sense why so many people feed their dog vegan, and why most of them do well on these diets.

After all the research I have done on raw and plant-based pet diets, and my own experience with veterinary diets and natural kibble diets, I am still at a loss for how people should feed their pets. Nutrition has no one absolute answer: every individual responds differently to various ingredients and macronutrient content. The one thing I can say with confidence is that raw food diets just aren’t worth the risk, but what about all the other endless pet food options? I myself practice a vegan lifestyle for the sake of animal welfare concerns and reducing my carbon footprint, but I’m not sure I could ever feed a dog vegan. At the moment I have cats, so veganism is simply not an option if I prioritize Milton and Oliver’s welfare over that of the animals they eat.

Someday I’ll get a dog, and given my own experience with vegan dogs generally not doing as well as omnivorous dogs, and the lack of randomized controlled studies (the gold standard for analyzing science-based evidence) to corroborate the claims made by vegan pet owners, I think I’ll stick with the high-quality kibble I know. To be fair, working with an integrative vet or veterinary nutritionist to design a whole-foods, home cooked diet may be the most optimal diet for animal health, based on the scientific reviews and claims made by vets practicing TCVM (Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine). But like I said before, I’m vegan, so there is no way I’m cooking meat when the site of raw meat makes me want to gag. To be safe, I would highly recommend feeding a high-quality, AAFCO approved kibble. These diets are much more affordable than raw or vegan diets, and you can have peace of mind that the companies were thoughtful in their diet design and were tested on real cats and dogs at home to guarantee that the theoretical benefits were actually achieved. The moral of the story: there are tons of options when it comes to pet food, some good, some bad, and some misleading choices that put your pet at risk with little benefit. Hopefully this series of posts can help in making that decision for your pets a little easier.

Images citation

Grandjean D, Buckley C, Charlton C, Merrill R, Morris P, Stevenson A. WALTHAM Pocket Book of Essential Nutrition for Cats and Dogs. Editors: Grandjean D, Butterwick R. Beyond Design Solutions Ltd, London, UK. 2009, pages 10-11

Raw Food Diets

A major facet of integrative veterinary medicine is Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine (TCVM). Fresh, whole food diets are the foundation of health and wellness when taking a TCVM approach, an idea that makes sense given the numerous studies showing what a whole foods diet can do to human health (especially plant-based!). Vets practicing TCVM often prescribe specific therapeutic fresh food diets to treat a myriad of conditions, such as barley and duck to control inflammatory diseases as Dr. Morgan describes in the Journal of Integrative Veterinary Care. Raw food diets are often believed to be the most wholesome nutrition available for cats and dogs; macro- and micronutrients are not subjected to high heat and processing that kibble diets go through, and as a result the nutrients are more bioavailable (meaning more nutrients can be absorbed through the digestive tract).

Many “raw feeders” will tell you how much healthier their pets are since going raw, how the light just shines off their coat and raw was the only thing to stop chronic itchiness. A simple google search will tell you that a shinier coat, better muscle tone, and improved dental hygiene are just a few of the benefits of feeding raw, but there is not a shred of scientific evidence to back this up. This is not to say that raw is necessarily bad, but rather there is a need for more research on the effect of raw food diets on canine and feline health. While many animals do well on these diets, raw foods pose their own set of risks that would never be of concern with kibble. Of chief concern is food safety. Raw food diets mean raw meat, a substrate teething in microbes, some harmless and some that can wreak havoc on the immune system. Several studies have been done showing that Salmonella, Clostridia, Listeria monocytogenes,Campylobacter and Escherichia coli are present in most raw diets, and while the majority of animals ingesting the food remain unaffected, humans are susceptible.

Still, there have been several reported cases describing severe salmonellosis in cats and dogs from eating raw meat, many of whom died from the infection (LeJeune, JT et al., 2001; Stiver, SL et al., 2003; Stone, GG et al., 1993). If these diets are mishandled, the pet owners feeding it could easily suffer from contamination as well. One of my earliest childhood memories was suffering from Salmonella food poisoning, and let me tell you, it was memorable for a reason. At one point I was so sick that I had to be wheel-chaired in to the hospital. Even if a raw feeder takes every precaution to prevent him or herself from getting sick, cats and dogs can continue to shed these pathogenic microbes into the environment, posing greater risk for infection for the general public. Most meat that people buy at the grocery store for their own consumption actually has E. Coli and other types of pathogenic bacteria, but any potentially toxic agents are cooked out. Obviously this is not an option for raw food diets since this would negate the point of increased bioavailability in feeding raw food, though other studies have shown that cooking meat does not significantly reduce bioavailability.

Many animal nutritionists believe that if fed appropriately, a raw food diet could deliver all of the essential nutrients a cat or dog would need, but homemade raw diets are usually created from recipes that have not been tested and likely lack certain nutrients. The vast majority of commercial raw foods have not been subjected to AAFCO clinical testing (or any other clinical testing for that matter) to ensure that animals actually do well. As someone who values transparency in the straight facts, I would be hesitant to purchase any nutrition-related product if the only claims that could be made about it were by the company itself. In one report, food samples from five raw food diets (three were home-prepared and two were commercially available) were analyzed for nutritional adequacy. All five diets were found to have several nutrient imbalances, including excessively high levels of zinc and an alarmingly low calcium: phosphorous ratio in the two commercial diets under study (Freeman, LM and Michel, KE, 2001).

The last point I want to bring up is the misconception that dogs are wild animals and should be fed as such. Dogs evolved from wolves somewhere between 10,000-14,000 years ago, and as a result, the two species have drastically different physiologies. A thorough and eloquent review by Buff et al. discusses the impact of various natural pet foods on canine and feline physiology. In it they compare canine and wolf macronutrient requirements; dogs prefer and are adapted to consume approximately 30% of their diet from protein, 63% from fat, and 7% from carbohydrates, which is in stark comparison to wolves, who should be consuming 52% protein, 47% fat, and only 1% carbohydrates. If you take a stroll through your local pet store, you’ll find right on the front label “95% protein, 5% fat, 0% carbohydrates” on a bunch of raw dog food, a diet much better suited for a wolf (though still lacking in fat, I might add).

Dogs evolved in part from their ability to digest anything available, including carbs and leftover fatty parts of meat that humans didn’t want, so why are so many people convinced that it is far more nutritious to feed their dog a diet better suited for a different species? Cats on the other hand have very similar requirements to a variety of exotic feline species all over the world. It makes a tad more sense to feed a carnivorous predator a raw, primarily meat-based diet, though the risks for contamination cannot be ignored. After all the research I have done, I still can’t quite figure out why so many pet owners are willing to pay a fortune for food when the risks for contamination and nutritional deficiencies are so great. My only guess: natural pet food companies jumping on the “organic” bandwagon to sell overpriced pet food. These companies continue to perpetuate the idea that kibble is unnatural and making our pets sick, but the evidence just doesn’t support this claim. Don’t get me wrong, kibble goes through quite a bit of processing before making it into the bag, which does reduce the bioavailability of the food to some extent, but when a high quality diet is thoroughly researched and tested in clinical trials, the vast majority of animals do great eating this food as their sole source of nutrition for the whole duration of their lives. Low-quality kibble diets certainly exist, but writing off all kibble completely would be a misinformed decision.

All in all, the costs of raw far outweigh the benefits. In rare instances it is the cure-all to chronic itchiness or stomach problems, but 9 times out of 10 it will put the animal and their owners at risk of food-borne illness and may not even meet all of your animal’s nutritional needs. If you are still considering raw feeding as the most natural way to provide nutrition to your pet, maybe consider feeding a fresh cooked diet after discussing with your veterinarian or animal nutritionist. Natural dietary supplements are used in conjunction with a whole foods home-cooked diet to ensure that all of your cat or dog’s micronutrient needs are met, but please consult with an expert before considering home-cooking your pet’s food. Cooking at least eliminates the risk for bacterial contamination, but your pet could still fall prey to nutritional deficiencies if a diet is not balanced appropriately.

What’s the best pet food?

The feeding of raw food diets for cats and dogs has been a growing trend in recent years as the public concern for whole ingredients in human food extends to the diets of our pets. Many pet owners who feed their pets raw believe it is the healthiest source of nutrition, providing a diet that more closely mimics that of their ancestors and thus resulting in improved vitality and longevity, but there is a myriad of research that says otherwise. Raw food diets are often used therapeutically among integrative veterinarians, following Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine (TCVM) practices. This is a topic of much debate within the veterinary community for several reasons: food safety concerns (for both pets and humans), meeting nutritional requirements, and whether it is physiologically appropriate.

Although raw food diets are often recommended for patients seeking integrative care, this is one aspect of integrative veterinary medicine that I am on the fence about. Integrative medicine combines the best of alternative AND conventional medicine, based on scientific evidence. So far we have looked at a few reputable integrative practices that have been proven time and again in peer-reviewed studies of their efficacy, as well as some practices that appear promising but where more research is desperately needed. I have been able to find various claims about raw food diets and personal accounts from pet owners who simply believe their pets are “healthier,” but limited research on cohort or case studies is available. In fact, a veterinarian I work with was telling me about how right here at UC Davis, veterinary researchers attempted to run a large cohort study following x amount of dogs eating a strictly raw food diet for years and observing their behavioral and physiological parameters, but too many of the patients were getting ill on the diet, and the study was quickly ended. Validated peer-reviewed studies discussing raw food diets largely conclude that they are not safe, for the pets consuming them nor the owners feeding it. These diets also pose greater risks for nutritional pitfalls, given the lack of AAFCO approval or any other outside agency to validate the nutrient composition outside of the companies’ own claims.

Image result for aafco

Look for the logo or AAFCO statement on your pet’s food!

But doesn’t it make sense that consuming the most wholesome ingredients would lend itself to synergistic benefits? Afterall, research continues to pour out on the irrefutable health benefits of unprocessed, whole foods to people. Though most veterinarians would not recommend a raw food diet, many others would never consider feeding a kibble diet to their pets, and one can easily find endless accounts of dogs suffering from various ailments finally finding relief through a raw food diet.

Plant-based diets for dogs are equally controversial in the veterinary community, but for very different reasons than its raw food counterpart. They are largely not supported by integrative nor conventional veterinarians because it goes against the Dog’s evolutionary history and carnivorous physiology. Nonetheless, it continues to be a growing trend as people become more concerned for the environmental and animal welfare implications of the animal industry. Thankfully vegan diets for cats is hardly debated, considering the fact that cats are obligate carnivores. Dogs, on the other hand, though far more carnivorous than us, are omnivores; they evolved to digest more carbohydrates and plant sources of food than their wolf ancestors. To many, it only seems right to extend one’s plant-based lifestyle to that of their companion if dogs are capable of digesting plants.

In the following posts I will present evidence based on sound scientific reasoning on the effects of raw and plant-based diets on our pets. Nutrition has no one right answer; not every single individual will benefit from the same diet, but some diets present more risks than others. The easiest and most prevailing decision any pet owner can make on the health and happiness of their pet is diet. By highlight the facts and exposing popular myths about pet nutrition, I hope the coming posts will help in making this important decision.

Acupuncture

Acupuncture was first described in Ancient Chinese practices thousands and thousands of years ago, in which practitioners used stone needles to let out small volumes of blood. Needless to say the practice has progressed tremendously since its primitive beginnings, being widely used today in human medicine and quickly gaining traction in the veterinary field. Still acupuncture has been debated in both the human and veterinary medical fields whether it is truly an effective treatment option, or just homeopathic mumbo jumbo. The SkeptVet, a veterinary blog questioning various practices, brings into question the legitimacy of science-based evidence supporting acupuncture. Given the nature of the treatment, designing well controlled studies is tricky; how do we know if an individual is actually experiencing benefits from the treatment, or if it’s just a placebo? With normal drug trials, one can easily give one group a sugar pill and the other group the experimental pill, but acupuncture is administered through sticking dozens of needles all over the body (hard to control for the Placebo Effect when you can’t exactly “pretend” to poke a needle through someone’s skin). Many other vets question the evidence, but enough successful clinical trials have been done in human and animal patients to prove its validity in alleviating the side-effects of many conventional Western practices, as well as enhancing these treatments, providing pain relief for an array of conditions, enhancement of immunity, and treating neurologic disorders all without any side-effects.*

Last week I discussed the benefits of laser therapy in providing pain relief, but cold lasers are not an option with cancer patients (if you recall, laser therapy stimulates cell growth, something we desperately want to avoid with cancerous tumors!). Acupuncture is often used in adjunct to pharmacological treatment of cancer since this alternative treatment can alleviate the distressing symptoms while providing much needed pain relief that is typically not fully mitigated by pharmacological means.

We all know that acupuncture involves a bunch of tiny needles poking you all over your body, but what’s going on at the physiological level? First, acupuncture practitioners strategically select points based on certain features, according to veterinary oncologist and acupuncturist Dr. Elizabeth Hershey; these points tend to be richly innervated and associated with muscular dysfunction or pain. Some treatments involve only targeting those points associated with muscle problems, other treatments are aimed towards hitting specific nerves. There is a diverse array of potential acupuncture points that the practitioner can select to create an individualized treatment.

Insertion of the needle itself begins a cascade of neurologic effects and interactions between different structures lying just under the skin. According to Dr. Fry et al., who recently published a review detailing veterinary acupuncture in its use for analgesic treatment, “these structures include blood vessels; specialized afferent nerve endings that respond to pain, touch, pressure, and chemical changes; immunomodulatory cells like mast cells; glands; and soft tissue structures like muscle spindles; collagen; and other connective tissues.” The grouping of these structures has been called a neural acupuncture unit (NAU), so named thanks to the synergistic effects of needle insertion with all these various structures and its impact on the surrounding tissue. Once the needle is inserted, interactions with the nervous system and more distant tissues can commence. This ultimately results in stimulation of serotonin and endogenous opiate release, such as endorphins, the body’s natural pain reliever. Sometimes neurohormones are also released, giving the patient a euphoric sensation for the duration of treatment.

Electroacupuncture is a common adjunct in the veterinary field. This involves applying a gentle electrical current to the needles to gain more vigorous and prolonged stimulation; high or low frequencies can be used to alter the neuromodulatory effects.

Remember the bouncy little poodle Maggie from last week? Maggie received both laser therapy and acupuncture to treat her chronic pain from a debilitating neurological disorder, Intervertebral disk disease (IVDD). Before starting alternative treatments, Maggie was cage rested and on NSAIDs (non-steroidal anti-inflammatory pain medication) for two weeks, the whole time barely able to walk without falling over. Maggie’s mom finally opted for an integrative approach since solely using conventional methods was clearly not working for her. After her second week of cold laser treatment and second acupuncture session, Maggie was able to walk again! Since IVDD is a lifelong genetic problem with no cure, Maggie needs to be careful when jumping or playing with other dogs since roughhousing can lead to flare-ups. When she does have flare-ups, Maggie will get a session of laser therapy and acupuncture to manage her pain and get her back to good as new.

Maggie receiving electroacupuncture at home!

Sticking needles in your skin may sound suspect, but acupuncture has been recognized (for the most part) as a reputable treatment. Though I only have hands-on experience in conventional Western veterinary medicine, when all else fails the doctors I work with won’t hesitate to refer their patients to an integrative veterinarian for a different approach. In fact, just a few weeks ago I encountered a frustrated client who has a large shepherd with terrible orthopedic issues. Bella never wanted to get up or be active anymore because moving just hurt too much. Normally this problem would be taken care of through surgery, but given this dog’s size and age, it’s a slim chance that a $3,000 procedure would resolve her problem. This dog was also unfortunate enough to have a ridiculously sensitive stomach; at this point the client wanted to maintain her quality of life through pain relief, but even the best pain medication for a dog with a sensitive stomach given at half the dose with a full meal resulted in immediate vomiting and diarrhea. When we realized that there were no other pharmacological pain relief options, the doctor finally recommended acupuncture and referred her to an integrative veterinarian. This concerned client was calling us every day for a week to find something that would work for Bella, and after suggesting acupuncture (which the client was very open to trying), we have not heard from her since.

Stories like this is what sparked my interest in integrative medicine. Conventional medicine works the vast majority of the time, but sometimes you’ll meet that overly sensitive shepherd or immunocompromised kitty and find that taking an integrative approach may be the only thing that can drastically improve their quality of life. Though I have been focusing on dogs for the duration of this post, I want to point out that acupuncture is something most species can benefit from, including birds and horses.

 

*I have not read through direct scientific studies on acupuncture as I lack the insight to know what qualifies as a well-controlled study. For the rest of the information presented, I rely on scientific literature reviews published in peer-reviewed journals, articles written by veterinarians (both acupuncture practitioners and not), and my own experience.

Laser Therapy

Laser therapy is arguably the most underrated alternative treatment available. It’s used to treat a broad range of physical ailments, including ear and various skin infections, orthopedic issues, hip dysplasia, bladder infections, muscle injuries, infectious coughs, lick granulomas, gum disease, fractures, neurologic conditions, osteoarthritis, pain, and aid in post-operative healing. But what exactly is laser therapy? When I first began researching this treatment, I was imagining a bunch of infrared laser beams aimed at the patient, kind of like the red or green lasers you see in movies when secret agents have to do cartwheels and acrobatics around the lasers to get to the other side.

The process is quite a bit different than I imagined; laser therapy is not nearly as dramatic, simply administered through a hand held probe device that sits directly over the site of treatment on the patient for mere minutes. Since it provides immediate pain relief, animals seem to really enjoy the procedure. In most integrative practices, the owner can even sit with their pet while receiving the treatment— working at a conventional veterinary hospital, I can attest that it’s nearly impossible for the owner to come back to the treatment area due to the animal restraint involved and over-stimulation of the lights and noise perceived by the animal.

Now, how exactly does it work? This type of laser therapy is often referred to as “cold laser therapy” to distinguish it from its hot, cauterizing counterpart used in surgical procedures. Cold lasers are not nearly as invasive and are much safer on the patient since nothing is being cut or cauterized. The mechanism by which cold lasers work is called photobiomodulation; photons from a laser source interact with cellular functions by inhibiting or stimulating biochemical pathways in the cell. This process is not fully understood, but our understanding thus far involves absorption by cytochrome C, an important photoreceptor in the mitochnodria (if you think back to high school biology, the mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell, turning nutrients into fuel the body can use). This results in global tissue effects, such as reduced pain and inflammation, increased blood and lymphatic circulation to the site of injury, and stimulation of the immune system, the combined effects of which speed up the healing process. An immediate release of endorphins (the feel-good hormone that acts as the body’s natural pain reliever) is an added bonus!

Image result for laser therapy cats

Image from Veterinary Practice News. Looks like this kitty is reveling in those endorphins!

In an article discussing the benefits of laser therapy to our pets, Dr. Nunn, an integrative veterinarian in Georgia, describes a case study involving a senior Akita suffering from hip dysplasia:

“We’ve had dogs who’ve been barely able to walk, then after a series of six treatments, they’re acting like puppies,” he says. “We treated a 100-pound Akita the owner couldn’t even bring in. When we got there to load him in the pickup, he was laying in his own urine.

After the first treatment, we were able to towel-walk him around. After three more, he was able to walk on his own. Then after six, he was running around the back yard.”

Hip dysplasia patients typically require six sessions of treatment, but the frequency of treatments, as well as time per treatment and photon frequency, will vary based on the individual’s needs.

In fact, my co-worker’s dog received integrative treatment from a holistic veterinarian right here in Davis when Maggie, the cutest bounciest little poodle you will ever meet, was in immense pain, walking hunched over and vocalizing signs of distress. She was soon diagnosed with Intervertbral Disk Disease (IVDD), a condition that causes intense spinal cord pain and back spasms due to a genetic anomaly in the cushiony disks that act as shock absorbers and separate her vertebrae. This is a life-long problem, flaring up if she jumps on or off things too hard or plays with other dogs too roughly. At first my co-worker treated her with NSAIDS for the pain along with strict cage rest, but she was still falling over whenever she attempted to walk due to loss of her hind limb function.

She finally decided to try a different approach. Maggie was then treated with a series of laser therapy sessions and acupuncture (stay tuned for more information on acupuncture next week); by week two of integrative treatment, she was back to her normal self, no longer hunched over and able to walk like the spunky little poodle she is. At this point my co-worker discontinued medication since she was improving so rapidly with these alternative methods. Now, Maggie rarely has flare-ups, and has received cold laser and acupuncture treatment only once since she was initially seen for IVDD a few years ago.

Image result for laser therapy cats

Protective goggles are a must since cold lasers emit visible and invisible radiation.

Besides orthopedic or spinal cord injuries, laser therapy is a fantastic alternative to medications to treat pain and inflammation. Arthritic patients come to mind as those who would significantly benefit from this treatment rather than taking expensive anti-inflammatory pain medication daily or coming in once monthly for an Adequan injection, an effective yet outrageously expensive arthritis treatment. Though most animals do well on it, Adequan has many side-effects, including vomiting, diarrhea, upset stomach, pain at injection site, depression, and abnormal bleeding, and when first starting the treatment it must be administered more frequently for the first 2 months before we even start seeing effects. Laser therapy costs about $35-60 per treatment, and effects can be seen immediately. It should be noted that the equipment is quite expensive (a single cold laser apparatus can cost upwards of $15,000!), thus it has not been widely adopted in veterinary practices. This treatment modality has been used for decades in humans, with its application in animals just beginning in the last 10 years or so. All species can benefit, but it’s primarily dogs who have been studied in laser therapy application.

Laser therapy is quickly becoming recognized as an effective treatment modality, and there is a push within the veterinary community to adopt it as a mainstream practice. The benefits are irrefutable, and the bountiful research can convince even the most conventional of Western veterinarians of its efficacy.

Hydrotherapy

Hydrotherapy is just what it sounds like, medical treatment through water, which can be accomplished in a pool or an underwater treadmill. Hydrotherapy has long been used in humans for rehabilitation after orthopedic surgery or injury, improving fitness (particularly among those suffering from obesity or osteoarthritis), and rebuilding muscle tone without risk of harm to joints or damaged tissues. Animal physiology really isn’t all that different from humans, so it should come as no surprise that hydrotherapy has been proven to be effective in countless studies to improve healing after orthopedic surgery or trauma and slow degenerative processes. This form of rehabilitation has been studied most notably in horses and dogs, though it would likely be a great treatment in other large animals with orthopedic issues. This is a great non-invasive treatment to complement anti-inflammatory and pain medication used after orthopedic surgery or as arthritis treatment, prescription diets and supplements for weight loss, or safely improving fitness for geriatric patients.

The various physical properties of water, including buoyancy, hydrostatic pressure, viscosity, temperature, and osmolality (chemistry jargon for the salt concentration of water), can all be altered based on the individual patients needs. According to Dr. King, who recently published a scientific review discussing the benefits of hydrotherapy for veterinary use:

  • Increased buoyancy reduces stress on the joints and surrounding tissues, which helps reduce pain and inflammation associated with weight bearing exercises.
  • Water viscosity is about 12 times stronger than that of air, thus the increased effort to move forward in water aids in activating muscles and improves muscle strength and joint stability.
  • Immersion of the limbs in water provides compression of equal magnitude all around the limb, increasing blood and lympathic circulation, which reduces swelling. This ultimately increases joint range of motion while decreasing pain.
  • Cold water therapy (cryotherapy) is commonly used in horses to decrease pain, inflammation, and swelling associated with soft tissue injuries. Though warm water therapy (thermotherapy) has been shown to relax horses and aid in decreasing pain and muscle spasms while improving healing, and is more commonly used in canine rehabilitation.
  • Exercising in water with higher salt concentrations has been demonstrated in horses and humans to reduce swelling, pain, and inflammation faster than without minerals added to the water.

Image result for horse hydrotherapy treadmill

Underwater treadmill image from Chiltern Equine Clinic

Underwater treadmills are most commonly used to improve muscle strength after limb, neck, or back surgery or injury and improve range of motion in compromised joints, but it’s becoming more and more popular for athletic conditioning and overweight management. Even overweight arthritic animals seem to enjoy the exercise since it makes the physical effort of walking weightless, so their inflamed joints don’t bear the brunt of gravity pushing down on them. Oftentimes animals are unwilling to use a limb after injury, but when submerged in a pool of water they will use their limbs to balance themselves due to increased comfort of warm water and resistance to forward motion. Even neurologic patients who have suffered spinal cord injuries benefit from hydrotherapy; oftentimes dogs lose hind leg function after a stroke or other neurologic disorder, but walking in warm, relaxing water on an underwater treadmill for so many sessions has “retaught” many dogs how to walk again.

Indeed, I had recently heard of a dog who had suffered a stroke and lost complete function of her hind limbs. She had a little cart for her legs, so she was still able to be somewhat mobile. Luckily the owner wanted nothing more than a full recovery for Gracie; every week she would drive 90 minutes to the nearest veterinary hydrotherapy facility, and after just a few sessions Gracie could walk again! She had no problems running for short periods of time or going up and down stairs, though Gracie does lose her feet and falls over every now and then. Needless to say her quality of life has drastically improved.

Surprisingly, hydrotherapy is more affordable than you think. Most sessions cost anywhere between $20-50, depending on the condition of your animal and whether pool-based or treadmill-based hydrotherapy is a better fit. For horses the cost is about the same, though some horse barns even provide on sight hydrotherapy that is included in the monthly rent. Sometimes one session is enough to aid in post-surgical recovery, other times hydrotherapy is best utilized long-term for pain management or weight loss. Veterinary hydrotherapy facilities can be found in every state of the United States, and there are several scattered all over Europe. In fact, we have hydrotherapy for our pets right in town at the UC Davis Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital. As long as you have a pool or a tub, you can even do hydrotherapy at home! First consult your veterinarian, it is important to not overwork your dog and ensure that you are meeting the best water conditions for your pet’s needs.

Watch the one minute video below for a touching story about how hydrotherapy helped a dog chronically in pain and paralyzed from the waist down.

Aromatherapy